Michigan’s iconic fudge culture

Atlantic City has saltwater taffy, Maine has lobster, and New Orleans boasts beignets. In Northern Michigan, we have cherries, pasties, and wine. But let’s be real—when it comes to sweet decadence, Traverse City has fudge! This creamy confection is more than just dessert; it’s a tradition. Found in nearly every Up North tourist town, fudge shops invite visitors to watch the mesmerizing process of its creation, sample its decadence, and take a piece of Northern Michigan home.

The Origins of Fudge and Its Journey North

Fudge wasn’t always a sweet treat. In the late 18th century, “fudge” was a verb meaning to clumsily adjust or fit something together. By the 19th century, the term evolved into a kid-friendly expletive—“Oh, fudge!”—used when something got messed up. Fittingly, legend has it that fudge itself was invented by accident in the 1880s in Baltimore when someone “fudged” a batch of caramel.

Fudge made its way to Northern Michigan, particularly Mackinac Island, thanks to Henry and Jerome “Rome” Murdick. In 1887, the Murdicks opened the island’s first candy store using recipes passed down through their family. Rome quickly discovered that making fudge on a marble slab not only improved its texture but also created a spectacle. Crowds gathered to watch, and a tradition was born.

Fudge as Entertainment

Rome wasn’t the only one to capitalize on fudge-making as entertainment. Rival shops joined the fun, each turning the process into a show. Skilled candy makers twirled the gooey confection, almost letting it drip off the marble table before dramatically folding it back. Some even used electric fans to waft the tempting aroma of chocolate onto the streets, luring visitors inside.

Today, Mackinac Island proudly claims the title of “Fudge Capital of the World.” With over 10,000 pounds of fudge made daily during peak season, it’s no wonder the island hosts an annual Fudge Festival. Events like “Fudge on the Rocks” pair this iconic treat with creative cocktails, ensuring there’s a sweet option for everyone.

Fun Facts About Fudge

Did you know fudge can last up to a year when frozen? That’s right! Its sturdy nature—thanks to ingredients like heavy cream—makes it perfect for shipping and long-term storage. Plus, it won’t melt on hot summer days, so feel free to stock up!

Fudge has also made its mark in history:

• The Scots had a similar treat called “tablet,” but fudge is smoother and richer.
• Canada holds the record for the largest fudge slab at 5,760 pounds!
• First Lady Mamie Eisenhower was such a fan that she created her own recipe, aptly named “Mamie’s Million-Dollar Fudge.”

Beyond Mackinac: Traverse City’s Fudge Scene

While Mackinac Island is famous for its fudge, Traverse City is no slouch when it comes to satisfying your sweet tooth. The area boasts an array of fudge shops that put their own local twist on this classic treat. From cherry-infused delights to maple masterpieces, Traverse City’s fudge scene celebrates the region’s unique flavors and traditions.

So, as you explore the cherry capital and its scenic surroundings, make sure to stop by one of the local fudge shops. It’s the perfect way to treat yourself and take a piece of Traverse City’s sweetest charm home with you.

More than Dessert

Fudge is more than a dessert in Northern Michigan—it’s a slice of history, a source of pride, and a cherished tradition. Whether you’re watching a skilled candy maker perform their craft or unwrapping a slice months later at home, fudge embodies the spirit of Northern Michigan: sweet, inviting, and timeless.

Why Choose Dyer Lake Vacation Home?

Much like a perfect piece of Traverse City fudge, Dyer Lake Vacation Home offers the ultimate blend of indulgence and comfort. Nestled in nature, it’s your sweet escape with convenient access to Lake Michigan’s beaches. Thoughtfully stocked and managed by local hosts, it’s crafted to feel like your home away from home.

Visit our photo gallery to see all the pictures of Dyer Lake Vacation Home.

Ready to book your stay? Book direct and save or you can book through Airbnb if you prefer.